"Plaintiffs'
crusade, targeting religious expression in the
federal government, serves no purpose other than
to waste judicial resources at a time in our
Nation's history when those resources are needed
in cases involving real threats to American
liberties," the legal group asserts.
The Freedom From
Religion Foundation, a state/church watchdog and
an association of atheists and agnostics, filed a
lawsuit in July to stop the engraving of "In God
We Trust" and the Pledge of Allegiance at the
Capitol Visitor Center.
During an initial
tour of the center, before it opened in December
2008, some members of Congress were irked that
there were no prominent references to America's
religious heritage. Congressman Dan Lungren (R-Calif.)
introduced legislation in May 2009 directing the
Architect of the Capitol to engrave the two
expressions at the entrance of the center.
The House and
Senate passed the resolution, which also corrected
mistakes in the center such as misidentifying the
national motto as "E Pluribus Unum" (Out of many,
one).
In its lawsuit,
the FFRF argues that the Congressional
appropriations "will give actual and apparent
government endorsement and advancement of
religion," while excluding nonreligious Americans.
"[T]he mandated
language diminishes nonbelievers by making
god-belief synonymous with citizenship," the
foundation says.
Despite the
lawsuit, the new engravings were unveiled late
September.
Congressman Mike
Pence (R-Ind.) commented, "This motto is now
permanently etched in the Center which now serves
as the gateway into the United States Capitol
building, and it is my hope that this will always
be a visible reminder of the faith from which we
come and the God who has so greatly blessed our
nation."
Now seeking
dismissal of the lawsuit, the ACLJ is representing
44 members of Congress in its amicus brief.
"Our position is
clear: The fact is that Congress acted
appropriately and consistent with the Constitution
with the inclusion of the national motto and the
Pledge of Allegiance in the Capitol Visitor
Center," the ACLJ brief states. "The words of both
the motto and the Pledge echo the conviction held
by this Nation’s Founders that our freedoms come
from God.
"While the First
Amendment affords atheists complete freedom to
disbelieve, it does not compel the federal
judiciary to redact religious references in every
area of public life in order to suit atheistic
sensibilities."
The ACLJ adds,
"This challenge is another misguided attempt to
alter history and purge America of religious
references."
Formed in 1990,
the ACLJ is dedicated to the ideal that religious
freedom and freedom of speech are inalienable,
God-given rights.